How capitalism killed the social media of abundance

How capitalism killed the social media of abundance | Tech

We killed Instagram. And we'll kill the next social media beast, too.In 2010, we were given a platform that did relatively few things: You could edit photos and post them on a grid, and your friends could comment on them. Even then we wanted it to change. We wanted DMs and Instagram Stories and more editing options and better search and an explore page. Tech executives wanted us addicted to it, wanted us to crave it, wanted it to be a necessary tool in our everyday social existence so advertisers would be able to reach us and Mark Zuckerberg could get another electric hydrofoil surfboard. As the app expanded to incorporate all of those desires, we turned into Violet Beauregarde, rolling around the floor, livid that the platform we’d begged to change had changed too much. If the expression take a bad thing and make it worse had no meaning, Meta's existence alone would afford it one.Hating Instagram is also as integral to the platform's existence as being able to post a photo. Like senior Vox reporter Rebecca Jennings wrote in The Goods: Being mad at Instagram is sort of like being mad at the president: Venting your frustrations about it is both a cathartic and logical response to a seemingly insurmountable problem, the problem of too much power in the hands of too few people.But over the past few weeks, what started as a complaint a decade ago has become a chorus of fury. Users are tired of Instagram and its parent company Meta copying the features of other apps. First it was Snapchat, and now it's TikTok and BeReal — a social media platform with the explicit intent of being more realistic than Instagram that consistently falls short of doing so. In an effort to replicate these apps' successes, the latest Instagram and Facebook updates simply exhausted users by, among other things, prioritizing recommended videos from creators you don't care about, shoving incessant ads and sponsored content in front of our eyes, and trying out expanded posts that take up more space on our screens. Photographer Tati Bruening made a post demanding that we Make Instagram Instagram Again. It was shared by some of the platform's most powerful users, including Kim Kardashian and Kylie Jenner. The post has more than 2.25 million likes, and the coordinated petition has nearly 300,000 signatures. Tweet may have been deleted (opens in a new tab) Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram, addressed the criticism in a video, and in an interview with tech reporter Casey Newton, he said Instagram would phase out a TikTok-y redesign and temporarily show users fewer recommended videos in the feed. But that change is only temporary, and by the end of 2023, Zuckerberg said that the number of recommended posts on Instagram will more than double. The trouble with an abundant audienceIn the early days of social media, we used the platforms to have fun and be ridiculous and post stuff for what you probably understood to be a limited audience, Aimée Morrison, an associate professor in the department of English language and literature at the University of Waterloo, told Mashable. Our friends saw our posts, but that was about it. The content was abundant, but the audience was not abundant. You imagined that nobody was interested, Morrison said. Social media has gotten a lot more noxious since then. Now anyone is like one Google search away from, 'Oh my God.' You're one Google search away from being fired from your teaching job for posting a picture of yourself drinking alcohol, one post away from forever having to relive what you thought was funny at 13 years old, or even one post away from fame. Before, there was content in abundance, but there was not self-consciousness in abundance. - Aimée Morrison, associate professor, the University of Waterloo I find myself missing the internet before the audience — the world in which we would go out to a party and someone would bring their shitty digital camera, and we would take 40 pictures, and every single terrible one would be posted to a Facebook album; a world in which I would write miss you babe! on my friends' wall a moment after she left my house. I miss the freedom of being seen only by my immediate friend group, and the freedom of not being forced to conform to an aesthetic that would grow to form not only who we are but what we buy, where we travel, who our friends are, and what our jobs are (or aren't).We're always in some ways curating the version of ourselves that we are presenting, Morrison said. Before, there was content in abundance, but there was not self-consciousness in abundance. It was more carefree, and we weren't thinking about all the possible audiences, the revenue opportunities, or the firing opportunities. We were heedless of consequence in ways that ultimately we had to give up, because the real world always comes for our social media eventually.A world ruled by the algorithm As a human teenager, I do remember fearing how the setup of my MySpace Top 8 could affect the IRL interactions I had with my friends. But nothing has ever felt quite as taxing as maintaining the humiliating facade that life online requires of us: the performative nature of posting anything, not being sure what the rules are for post frequency, and dissecting the internal need to share with strangers. Any of the carefreeness of social media has been ripped away from us; there's a certain ignominy of being online today. Tweet may have been deleted (opens in a new tab) In part, that’s because we've moved away from the social media of abundance, when people would post 50 photos from one night out and then 20 people would respond with inside jokes, as McSweeney's editor Lucy Huber labeled it on Twitter. Now we're moving toward social media not led by connecting with friends and family, but by algorithmic code. We only post once a year, with massive life updates, because our feed is no longer meant to remember a fun night out; it's meant to entertain us.Recommendation media, a term coined by Angel investor and Anchor co-founder Michael Mignano, is what you see when you open the ForYou page on TikTok or the explore page on Instagram. You're being fed content selected specifically for you by an algorithm that will make you stay on the app longer. In comparison, social media of abundance had virtually no algorithmic influence. BeReal is trying to bring that kind of experience back, but with less abundance (you can only post one photo a day). And even an app created with the explicit goal of overthrowing the algorithm overlords is weakened by the same pitfalls as its predecessors: Users plan their posts ahead of time and they crop out the mess. Recommendation media was never meant to be a place for connection; it was intended to provide a space for exploration, innovation, and knowledge, but it has somehow thwarted all three and left us craving our dearly departed social media of abundance. So, I went searching for her. I wanted to find where the social media of abundance lay, and asked her how she died, Pushing Daisies style. But when I finally asked her who killed her, she croaked out one slimy word: greed.The perpetual cycle of social media hellDuring the startup, venture capital phase of a social media platform, Morrison says the most important thing is user growth, which incentivizes platforms to build something that users actually like. But the platform is being built off of imaginary money, because it comes from venture capital, which will eventually run out.Once you hit a certain threshold of users and ubiquity and you think people are invested in your site, you start to run ads and you start to farm data from your users, Morrison said.When we first start using a platform, we get validation from likes, comments, and follows from our friends, which incentivizes us to use it more. Sabrina R. Merritt, the founder and CEO of October Social Media, told Mashable that Meta saw that and ran with it.  Once money enters the room, the art gets impacted. - Sabrina R. Merritt, founder and CEO of October Social Media The algorithm always changes when the focus becomes about money and using advertising as a source of said revenue, Merritt said. That's the business model of social: to have an algorithm in the beginning that is rewarding to all, and then once you have all the users and you've gotten people addicted to using the app on an ongoing basis, the model changes.So platforms start bringing in revenue via ads, and the most effective way to do that is to start to decrease the organic reach that's happening for users, Merritt said. Once money enters the room, the art gets impacted.People are brands, and everything sucksIn 2010, in the beginning of Instagram, we posted all the time, and we rarely saw ads. Then ads started taking up space, influencers started producing sponsored content, and eventually we stopped posting on the grid as often with the knowledge that our content wasn't going to be seen by our friends. We've begun viewing more content than we're sharing while still spending wild amounts of time online.You're competing with brands, you're competing with influencers and that stuff is generated to go to the top, Amanda Brennan, a meme librarian and senior director of trends at the digital marketing agency XX Artists, told Mashable.Now there are new (unofficial) rules of Instagram, according to a TikTok from Mark Plunkett:No filters (few exceptions)Insta stories [are] casualNo instagram birthday shout outsNever post on time for a real post (stories too sometimes)Comments mandatory (attendance taken + points for originality)Must respond to all pollsSpam accounts + finstas privateWhether you follow those or not, the new rigidity of social media makes us all act as if we're our own brand. Our aesthetic has to be curated. Everything has to be so slay all the time. Social media has become a job for all of us, and most of us aren't getting paid.Part of the reason why social media doesn't feel fun is because the communication around it is: 'You're a brand. Everyone is their own brand. Everyone is their own television network. You should be making videos,' Merritt said. All this pressure to produce not only content but a high level of content in conjunction with living your actual life.The future doesn't look great Knowing why our social media of abundance is gone, it feels inevitable that we'll never get her back. We're existing in a cyclical social media world: We join a platform we love, ruin it, and leave, only to join another platform we love and do the same thing.It's a human, psychological thing, Morrison said. Tech companies are tapping into a real need we all have for belonging, for community, and for dopamine hits. And they’re exploiting it. As soon as users find what they're looking for, it's taken away from them and replaced with revenue avenues for the tech companies, instead. Eventually we all become aware of being turned into donkeys, and it makes us self-conscious, and we clam up until the next one. - Aimée Morrison, associate professor, the University of Waterloo It's a startup-to-developed company cycle that's gonna happen over and over and over again, Morrison said. If you are not paying for it, you are the product. And eventually we all become aware of being turned into donkeys, and it makes us self-conscious, and we clam up until the next one.Twitter is losing users, fewer people are using Snapchat, and Meta is struggling, too: The company has lost users and hundreds of billions of dollars. I'm not sure where we'll go from here, if not just a perpetual fall into algorithmic hell. Mignano, the investor who talks about recommendation media, posits that we might see platforms like TikTok and Instagram start making their own content, the same way Netflix and YouTube have. Or perhaps professional media companies like Netflix will start creating social media platforms, given that Netflix’s co-CEO said that his biggest competitors were TikTok and YouTube.Taking a good thing and making it just a little bit worse is a natural part of the human condition. Think about frozen yogurt in The Good Place or taking air travel from its glamorous past to what is now barefoot, cramped, and led by the whim of TSA agents. Often, going from good to bad to worse is just what we can expect from ourselves. Social media gave us connection, then gave us increased risk for depression, anxiety, and self-harm, all while helping the spread of misinformation. It is only sensible that the same fear-fueled anticipation of watching a horror film might take over our minds as we prepare for what social media will become next. 

Read all

Podobné články | 17. 08. 2022 18:45:52 | Tech

Swiss startup Typewise is showing the power of sticking at it: The team behind patented text prediction technology — whose fascination with typing productivity started off as a consumer keyboard-focused side hustle more than five years ago — has gained backing from Y Combinator and will be in the cohort pitching to

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 18:40:42 | Tech

Tribe Capital recently named Boris Revsin as a Managing Partner at the venture fund. But little has been written about the entrepreneur turned investor, who went from dropping out of college to start his first company at the age of 19, to helping lead investments at a $1.5B fund.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 18:01:10 | Tech

SAVE $100: Need an upright vacuum to tackle tough messes? The very capable Dyson Ball Animal 2 is on sale for just $399.99 at Walmart and the Dyson website as of August 17 — that's 20% off its MSRP.While the rise of the robot vacuum has definitely done wonders for convenience, there still comes a time when you need to whip out the trusty ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 18:01:09 | Tech

Wednesday Addams (Jenna Ortega) is a peculiar child...but then again, she is an Addams. The macabre runs in her blood.In the teaser trailer for Tim Burton's upcoming Netflix series Wednesday, we get to see how Wednesday fares when separated from her family. After getting expelled from several schools — once for an incident involving piranhas ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 18:01:09 | Tech

SAVE $200: As of Aug. 17, the Layla Hybrid Mattress is $200 off the usual price (and comes with two free pillows). Get a queen size for just $1,499.Sleep is something that shouldn't be taken lightly. Without sufficient rest, your whole life can become a lot more difficult. It's harder to focus, harder to perform your daily tasks, and harder to reco ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 18:01:09 | Tech

If you've ever scrolled through Instagram and thought, "hmmm, this app would be so much better if it was just a little bit more like TikTok," then oh boy, do I have good news for you.In a video posted to their Facebook page on July 16, Meta announced a few changes that will continue to push the app toward becoming its biggest competitor, TikTok. T ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 18:01:08 | Tech

Before you raise money as a cash-strapped fledgling startup, it can feel like every problem you are experiencing would go away if you just had some money in the bank. At TechCrunch, it often seems as if every other startup story is about yet another fun company raising satchels full of venture capital. Millions —

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:50:54 | Tech

Apple TV+ has released the first trailer for upcoming original film "The Greatest Beer Run Ever," which stars Zac Efron and is set to premiere on Sept. 30.The Greatest Beer Run EverThe "The Greatest Beer Run Ever" tells the true story of Chick Donahue, who left his home in New York in 1967 to bring beer to his friends serving in Vietnam. Read more. ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:45:42 | Tech

Botswana has surpassed the UN's 95-95-95 goals on HIV. Researchers say that the country is on track to end the public health threat of AIDS by 2030.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:45:40 | Tech

JPMorgan Chase has been among the most aggressive and most public banks in its commitment to leveraging data and analytics to deliver customer and business value.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:31:03 | Tech

Bonus savings at checkout drive the price of the M1 Mac mini down to $569.99 at Amazon.Amazon has the cheapest M1 Mac mini price thanks to bonus savings at checkout.M1 Mac mini deal Read more...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:30:50 | Tech

In a new study published in the journal JAMA Network Open, researchers found that 56% of the people who were infected with the Omicron variant of the SARS-CoV-2 virus had no idea that they had caught it.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:20:42 | Tech

You need to understand the key differences between private equity and venture capital, especially in a difficult investment time period.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:10:14 | Tech

A "wrinkly" creature with no anus that was thought to be an ancient human ancestor is in fact not, scientists have found.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:01:11 | Tech

Nikhil Sachdev Contributor

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 17:00:58 | Tech

A real-world study on millions of South Korean teens found the shots offered “limited protection” against infection just weeks after the second dose, though they continued to provide strong protection against serious illness.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:30:53 | Tech

The first mistake was handing over my cell phone number.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:25:46 | Tech

Highbeam, a New York-based neobank built for people building e-commerce brands on marketplaces like Shopify and Amazon, raised $7 million in seed funding to continue developing banking tools that cater to these entrepreneurs’ needs. The one-year-old fintech startup, started by Samir Shergill and Gautam Gupta, provides banking features, access to tr ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:20:48 | Tech

Prominent Gen-Z TikTok creators and influencers are organizing against Amazon in solidarity with the Amazon Labor Union, refusing Amazon sponsorships and the monetization of their individual platforms for Amazon. The campaign, entitled "People Over Prime" and coordinated by advocacy group Gen Z for Change, consists of 70 creators who have a collect ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:20:47 | Tech

Google Chrome is the most popular web browser in the world, and it's already highly secure, making it the best choice for those worried about their privacy and safety online. One of the great things about the browser is that you can easily customise it and add extensions to personalise your experience. One such option is to add a VPN extension so t ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:20:47 | Tech

When is Thor: Love and Thunder going to be available for streaming, and why won't you give us a date, Disney?That's the question currently plaguing Marvel fans, with it now being well over a month since the new chapter in the Thor saga pummelled its way into theatres. Disney, however, still hasn't released a streaming date.So when can we expect Lov ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:20:47 | Tech

She-Hulk: Attorney at Law is unlike any Marvel show we've seen before. Yes, it's the story of a hero — Jennifer Walters, aka She-Hulk (Tatiana Maslany) — discovering their powers. And yes, it features several prominent MCU cameos. But this half-hour comedy about a lawyer-turned-Hulk has just as much in common with Ally McBeal or Legally ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:20:46 | Tech

While the impact of macro market conditions on the global venture ecosystem has dominated headlines and conversations since February, it occurred to me a few weeks ago that I hadn’t heard anything about Israel. No huge layoff perils — but no eye-popping mega-rounds either. Was no news good news? I decided to find out. In the f

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:15:43 | Tech

Everyone needs to update software regularly, so business and executive leaders should think of IT as a holistic system.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:05:51 | Tech

Apple's music app GarageBand for iOS and iPadOS has gained new DJ sessions based around Katy Perry and K-Pop group Seventeen.Apple has previously updated GarageBand for iOS and iPadOS to include "sound packs" from the likes of Lady Gaga. Now two free downloads for the app have been released to provide users with the ability to learn how to mix two ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:05:51 | Tech

All three color choices in the new Beats Fit Pro x Kim Kardashian collection are in stock at Amazon, with delivery as soon as tomorrow.Beats Fit Pro x Kim Kardashian are in stock at Amazon in all three colors.We reported that the Apple Store is sold out of all color options this morning, but Amazon currently has all three hues in stock for $199.95 ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:05:37 | Tech

Yesterday, the Twitter impressions embargo lifted on the first four episodes of She-Hulk, because that’s a thing we do now. Impressions were positive, but now today, the real embargo has lifted for full, scored reviews, and we now have a Rotten Tomatoes score as a result.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:00:56 | Tech

The challenges that retailers face every holiday peak season have been exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic, which accelerated the trend towards online shopping and highlighted weaknesses in the supply chain.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 16:00:56 | Tech

Zero trust has now become a gold standard for many organizations, and one of necessity. So what is zero trust and why does it matter?

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:55:47 | Tech

Wedbush has raised its Apple price target to $220 from $200 because iPhone demand is holding up as the company heads into its next cycle.iPhone 14 ProIn a note to investors seen by AppleInsider, Ives believes Apple has placed an initial order for 90 million iPhone 14 and iPhone 14 Pro units out of the gate. That's roughly flat compared to the iPhon ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:45:38 | Tech

Company culture can be as difficult to grasp as it is important to foster.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:40:43 | Tech

It’s that time again, where I collect some Bungie-based hype heading into the next season of Destiny 2. Once again we find ourselves in a similar situation where we know almost nothing about the actual content of season 18, only this time, it’s being revealed in a showcase alongside Lightfall.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:30:49 | Tech

They act as a stepping stone to achieving key tech business milestones and help everyone in an organization make better decisions. All parts of an organization can use and benefit from key performance indicators.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:25:33 | Tech

Distinguishing science disciplines as "hard" or "soft" is flawed and outdated. Here's why.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:15:41 | Tech

When people are given a chance to discover the benefits of new technologies for themselves, they generally move quickly toward adoption.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:10:43 | Tech

Critics and audiences disagree on The Terminal List, and I'm seeing echoes of Yellowstone in these debates.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:01:18 | Tech

Wednesday's best deals include $110 off an Apple Watch Series 7, $297 for an LG 27-inch 4K HDR monitor, refurbished iPhones from $139, and much more.Best deals August 17Every day, AppleInsider searches online retailers to find offers and discounts on items including Apple hardware, upgrades, smart TVs, and accessories. We compile the best deals we ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:01:01 | Tech

Optimization tools will enable the people who operate energy grids to manage the increasingly complex nature of energy grids and ensure the lights stay on, no matter the circumstances.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:01:01 | Tech

Emerging psychological research can help parents blunt the negative effects of adolescent social media use.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:01:00 | Tech

Whether helming major retailers' operations or managing service providers' data, 2022 will continue to throw curveballs at the CDOs tasked with understanding current best practices and the challenges of protecting vital data.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:01:00 | Tech

Agriculture can be a part of the solution to climate change through lower carbon transport fuels. The key is to meet that demand without needing more farmed land

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 15:00:59 | Tech

The iconic Audio-Technica AT2020USB+ has finally been updated to a USB-C interface and now has even higher sampling rate and a much improved stand for desktop use.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:55:37 | Tech

The best way to fight fires is to prevent them in the first place. Firefighters recount how constant vigilance with the help of technolopgy helps them stay ahead in a deadly game.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:45:38 | Tech

Yesterday, Mark Zuckerberg once again made the rounds being roasted on Twitter, not due to barbeque sauce or surfing, but because of yet another screenshot he posted from Horizon Worlds, this one a Facebook post celebrating the game coming to France and Spain.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:45:38 | Tech

As ransomware attacks multiply, most organizations tend to respond in either of two ways—by paying the ransom, which can amount to millions of dollars, or not paying and diverting resources to recovery efforts.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:35:41 | Tech

Multi-asset social investment network and Robinhood competitor eToro has signed a definitive agreement to acquire Gatsby — a fintech startup which also aimed to go head to head against Robinhood — for $50 million in a cash and common stock

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:30:51 | Tech

There will be many nuanced calls and compromises that your organization will face in its BI journey. But it's a journey well worth it.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:25:45 | Tech

Coaches and swimmers in Australia's The Dolphins national swim team are using Apple Watch, iPad, and custom apps to track health and performance.Swimmer Zac Stubblety-CookApple is celebrating how The Dolphins team is reportedly having its most successful period in history, because its members are so invested in technology such as the iPad. Read mor ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:20:59 | Tech

Anyone who's seen Normal People will know that Paul Mescal can act. But in God's Creatures, it looks like he'll be shedding his romantic image for something far less pleasant.In the trailer above for Saela Davis and Anna Rose Holmer's drama, Mescal plays Brian, a young man returning to an Irish fishing village to stay with his mother, Aileen (Emily ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:20:59 | Tech

If you’re a movie buff or enjoy nothing more than binge-watching box sets, chances are you've heard of Kodi. Kodi is a free, open-source software media player app formerly known as XBMB that acts as a hub for all your music, movies, and TV content, which can be shared across all of your devices.Benefits include being able to turn your gadgets ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:15:39 | Tech

Call of Duty is now being accused of taking a skin from Dr. Disrespect's DEADROP, one that is quite literally Robert Bowling's profile photo.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:15:39 | Tech

Global female tech leaders have introduced innovative new products and services, business concepts, career disciplines, and more.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:15:38 | Tech

Supporting mental health not only fuels a team’s best work but keeps them in alignment with their core values, which only maximizes sufficient protection for the organization itself.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:01:15 | Tech

A detailed new report says that a long-time bug in iOS prevents any VPN from fully encrypting all traffic — and also claims that Apple has known about it and chosen to do nothing since discovery in 2020The vulnerability was first discovered by VPN firm ProtonVPN in March 2020. At the time, the company said that when a VPN is switched on, the OS sho ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:01:02 | Tech

It is time for businesses to take the necessary measures to realign their businesses and meet these changes head-on. This is the right time to start if you haven’t already begun your journey because Web 3.0 is still in its starting phase.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 14:01:01 | Tech

AI Ethics earnestly wants AI to aid the UN Sustainability Development Goals (SDGs), but meanwhile there are uses of AI that undermine the very same aspirations.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 13:50:42 | Tech

The traditional office as we know it is gone, and the sooner companies adapt, the better.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 13:30:51 | Tech

While we are years away from fully autonomous robots that can think, act and error-correct on their own, robotic systems using supervised autonomy are being demonstrated today.

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 13:15:51 | Tech

Incredible Health, a US-based job-matching platform which made nurses its first focus, has closed an $80 million Series B funding round and announced hitting a $1.65BN unicorn valuation, billing itself as the highest valued “tech-enabled” career marketplace in the healthcare sector — a couple of (pandemic-struck) years after closi ...

Source: | 17. 08. 2022 13:15:41 | Tech

While blockchain platforms may be the darling of the Web3 application movement, there are a lot of thorny issues that make deploying them widely a major challenge.